Discovering the Best Bagels in NYC


New York City, often referred to as the culinary capital of the world, is famous for many delectable delights. Among them, the humble bagel stands out as a quintessential New York experience. In this guide, we’ll take you on a savory journey through the city’s streets to uncover the best bagels in NYC. From classic favorites to innovative creations, we’ve got you covered.

Discovering the Best Bagels in NYC

The Quest for the Perfect Bagel

The History of Bagels in NYC

Let’s start our journey by delving into the history of bagels in the Big Apple. These doughy delights have been a staple of New York cuisine for over a century. Immigrants from Eastern Europe brought their bagel-making traditions with them, and today, NYC is synonymous with these round, chewy bread rings.

Discovering the Best Bagels in NYC

Bagels arrived in New York City with Jewish immigrants in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. They quickly became a beloved staple, and by the mid-20th century, bagel shops were a common sight throughout the city. Today, they are a symbol of NYC’s diverse culinary heritage.

Best Bagels in NYC: An Overview

Before we dive into specific shops, let’s get a bird’s-eye view of the top bagel establishments in the city. With countless options to choose from, it can be overwhelming, but fear not; we’ve narrowed it down for you.

Discovering the Best Bagels in NYC

In a city known for its food, bagels hold a special place in the hearts of New Yorkers. These boiled and baked bread rings have a unique texture and flavor that sets them apart. From classic plain bagels to exotic varieties, NYC has it all.

The Bagel Hotspots


Nestled in Midtown Manhattan, Ess-a-Bagel is a legendary bagel shop that has been serving up fresh, hand-rolled bagels since 1976. Their signature bagels are generously sized, chewy, and available in a variety of flavors. Don’t miss their classic lox and cream cheese bagel!

The aroma of freshly baked bagels welcomes you as you step into Ess-a-Bagel. They offer an extensive selection of toppings and spreads, but the true star here is the bagel itself. Whether you prefer sesame, poppy seed, or everything bagels, you won’t be disappointed. The lox and cream cheese bagel is a fan favorite, featuring silky-smooth lox atop a perfectly toasted bagel.

Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company

For those looking for a taste of Brooklyn in Manhattan, head over to the Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company. Known for their traditional water-boiled bagels, this spot offers a wide range of spreads and toppings. Their Everything Bagel is a local favorite.

Discovering the Best Bagels in NYC

Step into the Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company, and you’ll be transported to the heart of Brooklyn. The aroma of freshly brewed coffee mingles with the scent of warm bagels. Their secret? Boiling the bagels before baking, results in a chewy interior and crispy crust. The everything bagel, coated in a flavorful blend of seeds and spices, is a must-try.

Black Seed Bagels

Craving a modern twist on a classic? Black Seed Bagels combines the best of both worlds. These Montreal-style bagels are wood-fired to perfection, resulting in a crispy exterior and a soft interior. Try their beet-cured salmon bagel for a unique flavor explosion.

Black Seed Bagels adds a touch of Montreal to the NYC bagel scene. These wood-fired bagels are a testament to craftsmanship. Each one is hand-rolled, boiled in honey-sweetened water, and then baked in a wood-burning oven. The result is a bagel that’s crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside. The beet-cured salmon bagel is a delightful blend of flavors, with the earthiness of beets complementing the richness of salmon.

Best Bagels in NYC

Bagel Hole

For bagel aficionados, Bagel Hole in Park Slope, Brooklyn, is a must-visit. Their hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels are small but pack a flavorful punch. The plain bagel with a smear of cream cheese is sheer perfection.

Bagel Hole may be small, but it’s big on flavor. Their bagels are hand-rolled and kettle-boiled, creating a dense, chewy texture. Don’t let the size fool you; these bagels are bursting with flavor. A plain bagel slathered with cream cheese is simplicity at its finest. Bagel Hole proves that good things come in small packages.

Absolute Bagels

Upper West Side’s hidden gem, Absolute Bagels, has been satisfying cravings since 1990. Their bagels are known for their immense size and delectable flavors. Try the pumpernickel bagel with scallion cream cheese for a taste bud-tingling experience.

Absolute Bagels has been a neighborhood favorite for over three decades. What sets them apart? Their bagels are enormous and come in a wide range of flavors. The pumpernickel bagel, with its rich, earthy taste, pairs perfectly with scallion cream cheese. It’s a combination that’ll leave your taste buds dancing.

The Bagel’s Timeless Legacy

Before we dive headfirst into the tantalizing world of contemporary bagels in NYC, it’s crucial to pay homage to the rich history of this humble yet iconic bread. Bagels have their roots in Eastern Europe, where they served as a dietary staple for generations. It was the wave of Jewish immigrants who arrived in the United States during the late 19th century that brought this treasured creation to the bustling streets of NYC.

The traditional method of crafting bagels has been passed down through generations of dedicated bakers. Today, New York City’s bagel artisans continue to honor this legacy, creating bagels that embody the quintessential New York experience – a chewy texture, a glossy crust, and, of course, the iconic hole at the center.

The Bagel Capital of the World

New York City proudly claims the title of the Bagel Capital of the World, boasting an astonishing array of bagel shops scattered across its five boroughs. But with so many options, where does one embark on a journey to find the absolute best bagel in NYC?

Manhattan’s Bagel Mastery

In the heart of Manhattan, where the city’s pulse beats strongest, you’ll find iconic bagel institutions that have perfected their craft over decades. H&H Bagels, Ess-a-Bagel, and Absolute Bagels are among the legendary names where bagel enthusiasts congregate to savor the irresistible combination of a crispy exterior and a tender, doughy interior. These hallowed establishments are revered for their commitment to the traditional hand-rolled and kettle-boiled bagel-making process, a labor of love that ensures the perfect texture and flavor.

Brooklyn’s Hidden Treasures

Venture across the iconic Brooklyn Bridge, and you’ll uncover hidden bagel gems like Bagel Hole and Bergen Bagels. These neighborhood bakeries have forged a devoted following for their artisanal approach to bagel creation. Each bagel is a testament to precision and care, resulting in a flavor profile that is nothing short of heavenly.

Queens’ Culinary Innovations

Even Queens, often considered the lesser-known culinary sibling of Manhattan and Brooklyn, boasts its own share of bagel brilliance. Queens Comfort, for instance, stands as a shining example where inventive bagel creations intersect with classic comfort fare. Here, you’ll encounter unexpected flavor combinations that will tantalize your taste buds and broaden your appreciation for the art of bagel making.

Beyond the Classic Bagel

While the classic bagel-and-cream-cheese combination remains a timeless favorite, the NYC bagel scene has evolved to cater to a diverse range of tastes and dietary preferences.

Bagels as Works of Art

Many establishments now offer an array of flavored cream cheeses, from scallion to lox-infused. Additionally, the toppings have expanded to include smoked salmon, avocado, bacon, and beyond. Bagels have transcended their humble origins, becoming canvases for culinary creativity. The possibilities are as vast as your imagination.

Dietary Diversity

For those with dietary restrictions, rest assured that NYC’s bagel scene is inclusive. You can easily find vegan bagels crafted without dairy or eggs, as well as gluten-free options for those with sensitivities. Whether you’re a traditionalist or an adventurous epicurean, there’s a bagel in NYC that caters to your unique palate.

Insider Secrets for Bagel Bliss

Before you embark on your bagel adventure in NYC, here are some insider tips to ensure your experience is nothing short of extraordinary:

Time It Right

To savor the freshest bagels, make it a habit to visit your chosen bakery in the morning. Bagels are typically baked fresh daily, and arriving early ensures you have first pick.

Create Your Culinary Masterpiece

Don’t hesitate to get creative with your bagel order. Mix and match toppings, experiment with various spreads, and dare to explore combinations you’ve never imagined. The NYC bagel scene encourages culinary experimentation.

Cash Is King

While many bagel shops accept card payments, it’s a good idea to carry some cash, especially when visiting smaller, family-owned establishments that may not have modern payment systems in place.

Read Also:- The Ultimate Guide to Boichik Bagels

Leave a comment